Winter cereals can replace corn in pig and poultry feed

Research carried out by Embrapa Trigo (RS) and Embrapa Swine and Poultry (SC) shows that winter cereals, such as wheat, oats, rye, barley and triticale, are viable options to replace corn in the formulation of feed and concentrates to feed pigs and birds.

In addition to reducing dependence on this grain in the South Region, whose production has not been sufficient to meet demand, the result expands the market for winter cereals, which occupy about 20% of the potential cultivation area.

The scarcity of corn in view of the growing increase in the production of animal protein and the idleness of productive areas in winter were the main motivators of the studies, which evaluate the economic and nutritional viability in the use of winter cereals in the composition of feed, in addition to cultivars most suitable for feeding pigs and poultry.

The idleness of areas in winter in the South Region, especially in Santa Catarina and Rio Grande do Sul, is estimated at more than 6 million hectares, considering spaces in fallow or with cover plants. Taking better advantage of winter to supply the animal protein market is the project that Embrapa is developing in the region, in partnership with various segments of the productive sector, industry and public authorities.

Consumption

Each Brazilian consumes, on average, 43 kg of chicken and 15 kg of pork per year. To meet this demand, it is necessary to produce around 30 million tons of grains such as corn, wheat, soybeans and others

Corn deficit increases spending and worries producers

Corn production in Brazil reached 100 million tons in the 2019 harvest. Of this volume, 43 million tons are destined for exports and another 4.5 million tons go to the production of ethanol. Of the total grains destined for domestic consumption, more than half are used for animal feed.

Figure 1 - Balance of corn production and consumption in Brazilian municipalities in 2019 and the current and future water and rail transport matrix in Brazil. Source: Santos Filho et al., 2020.

In 2019, the South Region produced 25 million tons of corn, an increase of 44% compared to the volumes achieved in the 2000s. With the exception of Paraná, which counts on the reinforcement of safrinha or second crop corn, the states of Santa Catarina Rio Grande do Sul has approximately half of the corn they consume available (considering production less exports).

Just to meet the demand of the animal protein industry, which last year accounted for a production of 2.7 million tons of pigs and almost eight million tons of chicken, 21.5 million tons of corn were needed. The corn deficit in the South Region is supplied by grains brought from the midwest of Brazil, with logistics costs that overload production.

Figure 2 - Difference between areas with annual summer crops and winter crops in the cities of Rio Grande do Sul and Santa Catarina. Source: Santos Filho et al., 2020.

The following table shows how corn production has accompanied the growth in pig and poultry production in the South Region:

Wheat and triticale are the best candidates to replace corn

Embrapa's research points, in particular, to wheat and triticale as energy foods with the potential to replace corn and soybean meal in diets for pigs and broilers, provided that adjustments are made to the levels of amino acids and energy to meet the requirements of the animals at each stage. “With nutritional value complementary to corn and soybean meal, these cereals are technically and economically viable for inclusion in the diets of pigs and poultry, and can supply a significant part of the demand for grains for these two species,” evaluates the researcher from Embrapa Teresinha Bertol .

Initial results show that the nutritional values of these cereals are variable, depending on the cultivar, the place and year of production. Therefore, it is essential to evaluate each batch of these raw materials before use in the production of feed.
One of the cultivars that showed good potential for feed composition was BRS Tarumã wheat, which has higher values of crude protein and metabolizable energy. “With a protein content close to 18%, this wheat was developed for animal feed in an alternative market to bread making, and has been used for more than 20 years in cattle breeding, now with the possibility to also meet the demand for pigs and birds,” explains researcher Eduardo Caierão , breeder at Embrapa Trigo. According to him, the cultivar has excellent energy value, very close to soybean meal, which also allows lower costs in this production item.

Other wheat, such as BRS Pastoreio and BRS Sanhaço , as well as the triticale cultivars BRS Saturno and Embrapa 53, had lower energy content, which increases the demand for oil in the feed. “The use of these cereals can be economically more advantageous in the phases when the animals present less energy demand, for example, in the gestation of the pigs. In the case of BRS Tarumã wheat, due to its higher energy content than corn and high protein content, the use is more productive in the growth and termination phases, when the demand for these factors is higher,” explains the researcher of the Embrapa Swine and Poultry Jonas dos Santos Filho.

Photos : Eduardo Caierão (wheat) and Alfredo do Nascimento Júnior (triticale seeds)

Barley is also part of the studies

According to nutritional assessments, the optimal levels for the inclusion of wheat and triticale in the pig diet are around 35%, while for barley these levels are between 20% and 25% from the growth phase. In the case of broilers and laying hens, levels of 20% to 30% of wheat or triticale inclusion are recommended, and up to 20% of barley in the feed from the initial stage.

According to Teresinha Bertol, these are the levels that allow the best combination of ingredients to optimize the balance of essential amino acids and that provide the best pellet quality (pelleted feed format). However, she points out that it is possible to completely replace corn with wheat or triticale in pig diets, as long as the necessary adjustments are made to the nutritional levels to meet the requirements of the animals at each stage.

Industry's approach to the productive sector

The use of winter cereals in the production of animal protein is nothing new, but the mobilization that brought together specialists, entities representing the productive sector and public authorities aims to provide greater security in the profitability of the grain producer and in guaranteeing raw materials to supply industry.

With the objective of increasing the area with winter crops, the government of the state of Santa Catarina - which is the largest corn importer in Brazil - launched, in the beginning of this year, in February 2020, the “Incentive Program for the Planting of Grains of Winter,” which is encouraging farmers to invest in winter cereals with the potential to compose the matrix of ingredients for pig and poultry feed. The program has the technical support of research institutions such as Embrapa and Epagri / SC, the supply of inputs and technical assistance from the cooperative sector and the acquisition of grains by the pork and poultry industry.

One of the challenges to ensure the supply of animal protein industry with winter cereals is the not always favorable climate, responsible for many frustrated crops in winter with rains in the pre-harvest that can result in loss of grain quality and even contamination by mycotoxins , causing fungi that cause complications in the animals' digestive system.

But for the agricultural expert of Seara's nutrition team, Herbert Rech, the agroindustry already has experience to adapt to the adverse moment: “Problems with crop frustration that affect the nutritional or sanitary quality of grains also occur in corn and other crops. cultures. It is up to the industry to know how to make nutritional adjustments to maintain the animals' performance.”

According to him, winter cereals need to compete nutritionally and financially with the other ingredients of the feed, such as corn and soybean meal, but without losing in quality: “It is important to evaluate that we are not talking about using the waste from grain production to animal feed. We need quality wheat, which meets the demand of the animal protein industry and not only punctual offers of grains that did not meet the requirements of bread making.”

Rech points out that “if the producer uses wheat with characteristics of interest for animal feed, such as greater energy, proteins and less fiber, it will obviously compete better with other commodities. Quality wheat is valued in any market, but it is necessary to study every opportunity.”

“There are no technical doubts about the use of winter cereals to feed pigs and poultry. What is under discussion now is the business model to make planting and use in feed possible, ”confirms Alexandre Gomes da Rocha, from Aurora Alimentos.

He defends the establishment of an indexation of the price of winter cereals to the price of corn: “With the pre-fixed price there will be a loss for one side. If the price of corn is low, the agribusiness loses by paying dearly for winter cereals; and in the opposite scenario, the producer loses the opportunity for a better price of wheat. In the event of successive losses to one side, the business tends to lose strength and discontinue. That is why there is a need for a clear, pre-defined model that provides security for both sides.”